Risks of decentralisation

Author: Maksym Bryzitskyi, expert on legal issues

Decentralisation as a global trend of recent decades is possibly associated with the end of the Cold War and tiredness from central management on both sides of the Cold Curtain, which is especially noticeable in the countries of Eastern and Central Europe, where relevant reforms were a reaction to the failure of the policy led by the communist regime. The accumulated since that time empirical material and conducted researches give an opportunity to governments of other countries to evaluate the benefits of decentralisation and, what is more important, to minimize its risks.

The window of opportunities for the reform of powers decentralisation in Ukraine opened in 2014, when, according to the classical theory made by Kingdon, three conditions coincided together, such as a presence of a problem, offers for its resolving, and political will. Thus, the problem of the administrative system and local self-government always remained at the top due to efforts made by expert environment and interested parties, and because of the obvious inefficiency of domestic models in comparison with western neighbours. Detailed proposals on reforming have also been developed since the early 2000s and they have constantly been complemented by new ones. The factor that contributed to the consolidation of political will and that was not present in previous attempts to make reforms (1997, 2005, 2008-2009) became a necessity to suggest an alternative to the idea of federalisation of Ukraine promoted by pro-Russian forces.

Within five years, there have been significant changes in the territorial, administrative and financial structures, and the reform has repeatedly been called one of the most successful in the country. The hromadas, which used the procedure of voluntary amalgamation, have received considerable powers and resources, and most of them demonstrated high achievements in the arrangement of transport and social infrastructure, the provision of administrative services, optimization costs. The results are also confirmed by public opinion: the public opinion researches for three years in a row have recorded about 40% of the respondents, who have seen improvements in their settlements, against 5% who say that the situation has become worse.

However, the real big changes are still ahead. The first risk, which is usually indicated by opponents of decentralisation, is weakening the state’s ability to redistribute income and wealth, that is to reduce economic inequality.

Another risk is reducing the management effectiveness in comparison with centralised government vertical.

The next risk is the decline in macroeconomic stability.

And the last risk, which may be associated with decentralisation, is corruption.

The full version is available in Ukrainian – please click HERE

Колонка відображає винятково позицію її автора. За достовірність інформації відповідає автор колонки. Точка зору редакції порталу «Децентралізація» може не збігатися з точкою зору автора колонки.
19.09.2019 - 13:02 | Views: 16359
Author list 9aaa7b0032923c9f6ee50a42b7827e4d

Author: Максим Бризіцький


Maksym Bryzitskyi

Share the news:


To add comment you should be authorized or sign_in
Read more:

01 December 2021

30 November 2021

Municipality budgets: the Parliament has passed bill №5600 as a whole

Municipality budgets: the Parliament has passed...

On November, 30, 2021, the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine passed in the second reading and as a whole bill №5600 On...

30 November 2021

Draft amendments to the Constitution in terms of decentralization: what they involve and what the further steps are

Draft amendments to the Constitution in terms...

On November, 30, 2021, draft amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine in terms of decentralisation were publicized...

30 November 2021

The Parliamentary committee has publicized draft amendments to the Constitution in terms of decentralisation

The Parliamentary committee has publicized...

A joint communique and draft amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine in terms of decentralisation have been...

30 November 2021

95 municipality applications for institutional support in establishing an ASC have been obtained by the PROSTO project

95 municipality applications for institutional...

95 applications from 24 oblasts of Ukraine were sent by local self-government representatives for institutional...