Tough debates: arguments left unheard by opponents

Tough debates: arguments left unheard by opponents

The uneasy debates on whether hromadas should amalgamate were held in the city of Yampil, Vinnytsia Oblast. The “AGAINST” party told “horror stories”, did not notice the obvious things and still stood to their ground.

By Dmytro Synyakhttps://decentralization.gov.ua/uploads/ckeditor/pictures/1337/content_content_%D0%A1%D0%98%D0%9D%D0%AF%D0%9A.jpg

Lost round

At the end of the debates the “AGAINST” party stated that they did not renounce their convictions, although the arguments of the “FOR” party could not but be heard.

 

https://decentralization.gov.ua/uploads/ckeditor/pictures/1339/content_IMG_2882.JPG

 

“I think that those, who are currently not accepting the reform, simply oppose novelties.” said Oksana Harnets, head of the Swiss-Ukrainian project “Decentralisation Support in Ukraine” (DESPRO). But the next step will necessarily be to analyse and accept these changes. The reform is irreversible. Therefore, it is better to join it and even lead it rather than to stay aside, waiting for someone to make a decision for you.”

 

https://decentralization.gov.ua/uploads/ckeditor/pictures/1341/content_IMG_2776.JPG

 

The argument about the infrastructure subvention funds, not received by three rayons, represented by the “AGAINST” side, had almost no impact.

The argument about incapacity of small hromadas has not passed as well.

No horrible horror stories

The “AGAINST” side also repeatedly mentioned the old horror stories, which their opponents almost did not pay attention to. For example, Tetyana Kolun noted that the hromada of her village opposes joining the city of Mohyliv-Podilskyi, because now children’s way to school makes 300 metres, and after its closure after amalgamation, they will have to go too far.

 

https://decentralization.gov.ua/uploads/ckeditor/pictures/1338/content_IMG_2863.JPG

“It is up to hromada to decide whether to close the school or not,” added Vitaliy Hodnyi. “There are two small schools in the Tomashpilska AH with 50 pupils in each. And their closure is not even mentioned. Parents have decided this way – that’s it!

Authors comments

First of all, the process of reducing the number of village councils and underfilled schools will go independently of power decentralisation. Secondly, if the village council and a school are the largest employers in the village, then such a village will fail in any case. Thirdly, people in AHs decide on their own whether they need a small school and five employees in the village council.

The full version is available in Ukrainian – please click HERE

Further information on the Yampil debates to be featured in the following materials of decentralisation.gov.ua

More information on DESPRO debates is available HERE

 

Tags:

DESPRO debates

Область:

Вінницька область

Source:

Share the news:

Read more:
C8ecb5ef13994590e56e198dbc948179

13 December 2018

Успішні кейси ОТГ: як Славська громада стала...

Реформа децентралізації встигла прижитися на Львівщині і вже можна побачити деякі її успішні результати. На...

6a829f408f42aca21a1310ba6a1f6c89

11 December 2018

Local budgets in 2019 – experts comment the law...

On 7 December, the President of Ukraine signed the Law of Ukraine “On the State Budget of Ukraine for 2019” (No....

E2e5765b0e5bca08114264c04a647350

11 December 2018

“Nobody likes to be removed from the...

142 cities of oblast significance and 238 cities of rayon significance shall act as centres of amalgamated hromadas...