Urban agglomerations already exist in Ukraine in functional terms, but they have yet to become institutional realities. The state has recognised them in law, but there is still no mechanism for making them work. Stepan Kuibida, Adviser to the Minister for Communities, Territories and Internally Displaced Persons of Ukraine and co-founder of the Lviv Can Do More initiative, explains what needs to be done to ensure that communities surrounding major cities stop fighting their battles in court and start developing together.
Decentralisation has taught communities how to manage their own affairs within their respective boundaries. But major cities have long since outgrown those boundaries. People may live in a suburban community but work, receive medical treatment or study in the regional centre. Their daily lives are not constrained by administrative boundaries. Yet planning, budgets and management decisions remain confined within the limits of individual communities.
In my view, this is the main problem facing Ukraine's urban agglomerations: the disconnect between the geography of people's everyday lives and the geography of governance. Urban agglomerations already exist in functional terms. Institutionally, however, they have yet to materialise.
The state has formally acknowledged this challenge. The State Strategy for Regional Development provides for the creation of a legislative framework for the functioning of urban agglomerations. In November 2025, the Government introduced a classification of functional territorial types through Resolution No. 1493. In May 2025, Law No. 4425-IX amended Article 4 of the Law on Cooperation between Territorial Communities, adding a new form of cooperation: the establishment of an urban agglomeration. However, this provision will only become operational once a separate law setting out the procedure for establishing urban agglomerations is adopted. That draft law has not even been submitted to Parliament yet.
The consequences of this uncertainty can be seen across the country. Kyiv and Kotsiubynske have been locked in legal disputes for years over thousands of hectares of Bilychi Forest. Cherkasy and the Ruskopolianska community are disputing almost 600 hectares near Heronymivka, earmarked for the expansion of the regional centre in Cherkasy's master plan. Odesa and its neighbours are at odds over the master plan for Tairove, while Lviv and Sokilnyky are in dispute over the master plan and development boundaries. The underlying logic is the same in every case: one community makes a decision, its consequences are felt by everyone around it, and the parties try to resolve the matter in court.
There are positive examples, too. The Lviv urban agglomeration has made more progress along this path than any other. Its development has included a study of links with neighbouring communities, supported by the Council of Europe in 2021; the first cooperation agreement with the Bibrka community; a joint development strategy; and, ultimately, the establishment of the Lviv Urban Agglomeration Association, which now brings together thirteen communities. Local residents also support the idea: 88% of those surveyed in Lviv and neighbouring communities are in favour of cooperation between them.
In other words, there is a willingness to cooperate. What is missing are the rules. Below are seven steps which, in my view, are essential to making urban agglomerations work in Ukraine.
The state has already recognised an urban agglomeration as a form of inter-community cooperation. But without a separate law, this provision remains merely declarative. In other words, the top league has been announced, but the rules of the competition have yet to be established.
The law must answer some basic questions: who can initiate the establishment of an urban agglomeration? Which communities can join it? What powers should be transferred to the joint level? How should decisions be made, and where should the funding come from? Without clear answers, communities can only cooperate on individual projects, while integrated governance across urban agglomerations remains impossible.
At the same time, there is no reason to wait for the law before taking practical steps. Existing legislation already allows communities to implement joint projects, jointly operate municipal enterprises, and establish shared institutions and infrastructure facilities. This is enough to get started, but not enough to deliver spatial planning, a unified transport policy or long-term joint funding.
Moreover, before adopting the law, we need to determine which model is best suited to Ukraine. There is no universal model: every country chooses its own approach. Bottom-up initiatives are precisely what will allow us to answer this question in practice.
An urban agglomeration cannot be drawn on a map with a pair of compasses. Its boundaries are determined not by the number of kilometres from the city centre, but by how people live: where they travel to work and study every day, where they access healthcare, and which communities are connected through shared water supply, electricity or public transport networks.
When defining the boundaries of urban agglomerations, we should therefore move away from fixed-radius models and towards an analysis of functional connections. The necessary tools are already available: commuting data, transport flows, labour market analysis and sociological surveys. This was precisely the approach used in 2021 to identify the communities with the closest links to Lviv.
An urban agglomeration is neither a new administrative unit nor a means of 'annexing' neighbouring communities to a major city. Communities retain their boundaries, budgets, councils and political autonomy. They transfer to the joint level only those matters that cannot objectively be addressed effectively by individual communities acting alone:
A clearly defined list of functions allays the main concern of smaller communities: losing their autonomy. At the same time, it gives the major city a clear framework for its responsibilities.
For an urban agglomeration to avoid falling apart at the first sign of conflict, it needs an institutional foundation: a joint governing body with clearly defined powers and a professional executive office responsible for preparing decisions and overseeing their implementation.
I would particularly emphasise the principle of a double majority. A decision must be supported both by a majority of the communities and by communities representing the majority of the agglomeration's population. This mechanism protects both sides. A major city cannot overpower its smaller neighbours, while smaller communities cannot block the development of the major city.
European experience shows that this model works. The Stuttgart Region brings together 179 municipalities and has had its own Regional Assembly since 1994, jointly overseeing regional planning, the S-Bahn network and economic development. Poland's Upper Silesian-Zagłębie Metropolis (GZM) brings together 41 cities and municipalities, with a population of more than two million, and is responsible for transport and spatial development under a dedicated law.
Behind most conflicts between communities lies one question: money. Suburban areas attract new residents, development, land and a share of tax revenues. The regional centre, meanwhile, faces additional transport flows and increased pressure on its roads, schools, hospitals, water supply and public transport.
Yet Ukraine still lacks a stable formula that would answer three straightforward questions:
As long as there is no such formula, cooperation will depend on personal agreements between community heads and annual budgets. This is rather like building a bridge without knowing whether there will be enough money to complete the other half. Stability in local leadership does not solve the problem either: even where community leadership remains unchanged for years, there may still be no agreed strategy with neighbouring communities. Lviv is a case in point.
Urban agglomerations therefore need multi-year budgets, community contributions calculated according to a transparent formula, funding sources established by law, and state co-funding for joint projects. For example, GZM is funded through a legally prescribed share of personal income tax, community contributions and transport revenues, while communities in the Stuttgart Region pay general and transport levies.
Today, decisions are made locally, while their consequences extend across the entire agglomeration. One community approves large-scale development, but the resulting pressure on infrastructure is also borne by its neighbours.
The dispute between Lviv and Sokilnyky is a case in point. It is often presented as a dispute over the airport, but these are two separate issues. Lviv Airport is a state-owned enterprise under the authority of the Ministry for Development, and its airfield is jointly used with the Ministry of Defence. Restrictions on development in its vicinity are therefore governed by aviation regulations, not by decisions of the city or village council. The actual dispute concerns land use and urban planning, specifically the Sokilnyky master plan and development boundaries. The master plan, approved in late 2024, remains in force, while the lawsuit brought by Lviv City Council is once again being considered on its merits following a Supreme Court ruling.
Does every community have the right to its own master plan, provided it complies with the law? Yes. Can another community decide for it what can be built and where? No, because that would no longer be local self-government but feudalism. But can a community ignore its neighbour within a shared urban agglomeration? No, it cannot.
To ensure that such disputes are resolved around the negotiating table rather than in court, two instruments are needed:
This is how the Stuttgart Region operates, for example: the master plans of all 179 municipalities must comply with the joint regional plan.
Even the best model on paper will change nothing if we spend years waiting for it to be adopted. That is why, alongside regulatory changes, every agglomeration initiative should select two or three specific projects and implement them under the existing Law on Cooperation between Territorial Communities.
These could include a joint public transport route, a waste sorting facility, a backup water supply system or a coordinated investment map. For example, ideas for joint projects considered during the development of the Lviv Urban Agglomeration Strategy included the Lviv City Express suburban railway, an integrated transport ticket and a shared public transport network. It is now time to turn these ideas into concrete projects.
However, this requires changes at national level. At present, routes running through several communities within a region are organised by the regional administration, rather than by the communities themselves. Nor is there an integrated ticket for the agglomeration: Lviv has its own electronic ticketing system, while regional routes operate under a separate payment system. The state must therefore allow communities to jointly commission transport services and introduce an integrated ticket. Urban agglomerations themselves should publish open performance indicators so that residents can see the tangible results of cooperation.
Yes, cooperation is considerably more difficult than political battles over land. It requires compromise and mutual respect on both sides. But it is also far more effective. And this, in my view, is what true leadership by a major community looks like.
The success of an urban agglomeration should not be measured by the number of memoranda signed or the area it covers on a map. There are three straightforward criteria:
This can only be achieved by pursuing two approaches simultaneously. The first is practical: implementing joint projects under existing legislation, starting today. The second is regulatory: adopting a law on urban agglomerations, establishing a funding formula, introducing agglomeration-level impact assessments and making coordinated planning mandatory. The first approach will deliver quick results that can convince sceptics. The second will ensure that these results are not lost when community leaders change.
Agglomeration governance is not another layer of bureaucracy. It is a way of turning the scale of a large urban region from a source of conflict into a shared economic advantage. And in the context of reconstruction and preparations for EU accession, it is also a tool without which communities will find it considerably harder to attract investment and European funding.
This opinion article reflects solely the views of its author. The author is responsible for the accuracy of the information provided. The views expressed may not necessarily reflect those of the Decentralisation portal's editorial team.
19 November 2026
Біорізноманіття в містобудівних рішеннях: що варто врахувати громадам
Біорізноманіття в містобудівних рішеннях: що...
Наказом Мінекономіки та довкілля України від 13 листопада 2026 року № 2740 затверджено Методичні рекомендації щодо...
18 November 2026
Громада чи її органи: чому Україні варто...
Коли йдеться про такі речі, як правильний переклад міжнародного договору, це часто видається суто технічним...
18 November 2026
Безпечне дитинство: бюджетні пріоритети та спільна відповідальність держави і громад
Безпечне дитинство: бюджетні пріоритети та...
24 листопада о 14:00 в Українському кризовому медіа-центрі відбудеться публічна дискусія «Безпечне дитинство:...
17 November 2026
Стартувала програма для організацій, які хочуть...
Нові послуги та можливості для організацій, які підтримують підприємців та/або ветеранів і ветеранок та хочуть...