On 22–23 October, the III International Forum of Agglomerations in Ukraine was held in Lviv. Its main focus was on cooperation between communities in functional territories. We discussed how communities can work together, what changes are needed at the national level to achieve this, and what international experience could be useful for Ukraine.
Over two days of discussions with representatives of communities, central government, international organisations, and European metropolises, I gained even greater conviction in one thing: the next important stage in Ukrainian decentralisation needs to be the further development of horizontal cooperation between communities.
To achieve this, we need, primarily, not new administrative structures, but financial instruments that will enable communities to implement joint projects.
Decentralisation has undoubtedly become one of the most successful reforms in Ukraine. We now have new, significantly larger and more capable communities. The main achievement of the reform is not even the increase in local budgets, but a fundamentally different system of territorial governance.
Communities have been given real powers, resources, and the opportunity to set their own development priorities.
However, the reform was the result of a certain compromise.
Its original rationale was to create communities that were as self-sufficient as possible. However, it was impossible to implement this principle in full. If we had formed communities solely on the basis of economic self-sufficiency, huge administrative entities might have emerged around large cities, sometimes comparable in size to a significant part of the relevant region.
A sensible territorial balance was therefore struck. We have preserved individual communities, their autonomy and their own local governments.
This compromise, however, comes at a price. The administrative boundaries of communities do not always correspond to the actual economic and social links between territories.
This is most evident around large cities. A person might live in one community, work in another, take their children to school in a third, and use a hospital in a fourth. For them, this constitutes a single space of everyday life. For local governments, however, it means four different budgets, four management systems, and four sets of priorities.
This is where the problems begin. How should public transport be organised between communities? Who should fund a shared road? How can several neighbouring localities be supplied with water? Where should sewage treatment plants be built? How can a joint waste management system be established?
These issues often cannot be effectively resolved within the boundaries of a single community. We have learnt to manage communities separately. Now we need to learn to effectively manage what unites them.
Ukraine is not unique in its problems. Different countries have attempted to resolve them in two main ways.
The first way is to consolidate municipalities by merging them into larger administrative units. This is largely the path Ukraine has taken.
The second way is to preserve the autonomy of municipalities, but to create mechanisms for them to cooperate in tackling shared challenges.
We considered several such models at the Forum. For example, Sweden has relatively flexible forms of inter-municipal cooperation. Romania has its own experience of establishing inter-municipal development associations. In contrast, Italy, with its metropolitan cities, and France, with its well-developed system of inter-municipal associations, demonstrate far more institutionalised models.
Each has its own advantages and disadvantages. I, for example, am in many ways impressed by the French approach, with its strong inter-municipal associations. However, there are issues with the delineation of powers and responsibilities between the different levels of authority. I therefore do not advocate mechanically copying any single model.
We have to preserve the key achievement of decentralisation – the autonomy of communities. Basic services for residents, local development, and the management of their own resources have to remain at community level.
However, complex infrastructure issues – transport, water supply, sewerage, waste management – can certainly be tackled jointly. Moreover, I am convinced that many small communities would be happy to delegate some of these complex tasks to joint institutions. But on one condition: that these institutions have the necessary resources.
This is probably one of the main conclusions I drew from the Forum. After all the panel discussions and conversations with community leaders, experts, and international partners, a fairly clear picture emerges: what Ukrainian communities lack most today is not organisational models, but the funds to implement joint projects.
Take the Lviv agglomeration as an example. We have a voluntary association of local governments. Communities can reach agreements, set joint priorities, prepare projects, and establish the necessary mechanisms for cooperation. I see no need to create a separate supra-municipal authority for the Lviv agglomeration. Our main problem is the lack of sufficient resources to implement projects that bring communities together.
For example, one of the most important tasks is the development of a joint transport system. This includes inter-municipal bus routes, the transport integration of communities, and the restoration of a fully-fledged suburban rail service, in particular the implementation of the Lviv City Express. Such projects do more than simply improve transport. They make it easier for people to get to work, school, and hospitals; they create a larger shared labour market; and they open up new opportunities for economic development.
Another example is water supply and sewerage. We still face a situation where a significant proportion of residents in rural and suburban areas do not have access to a high-quality centralised water supply, let alone adequate sewerage systems. In the 21st century, this is unacceptable! But is it sensible for every small community to build its own treatment plants? This is often extremely expensive, economically unviable, and sometimes even creates additional environmental risks. It is far more efficient to create shared systems that serve several communities.
Here, scale effects come into play: a larger system can provide better quality services at a lower cost per resident. The same applies to waste management, major infrastructure projects and other shared services. But all this requires investment, which is often beyond the means of individual communities.
In my view, we should be working in at least two directions today.
The first one is to review approaches to the use of reverse subsidies.
Most large cities, around which potential metropolitan areas are forming, are economically viable communities. Accordingly, they often make reverse transfers to the state budget. I do not propose completely abolishing budgetary equalisation mechanisms. We have to support less financially capable communities, especially in frontline regions where the situation is extremely difficult. But at the same time, we need to stimulate the development of economic drivers.
It is therefore worth considering the possibility of channelling part of the reverse subsidy funds towards inter-municipal projects. And exclusively those that create shared infrastructure and benefit residents of several communities. This could serve as an effective incentive for cooperation.
The second direction is targeted state support for inter-municipal projects.
For example, the State Fund of Regional Development should have a separate funding stream for such projects. A similar approach could be applied in state programmes for the development of drinking water supply, sewerage, transport, and critical infrastructure. If several communities jointly plan an infrastructure project that will serve a large territory, such a project should have access to the relevant state financial instruments.
These two mechanisms are not mutually exclusive. On the contrary, they should be developed in parallel. In the context of war, it is hardly realistic to expect a rapid, large-scale overhaul of the tax system. Instead, the creation of targeted funding instruments for inter-municipal cooperation could prove to be a perfectly practical solution.
The question is sometimes raised: why should the state provide additional support to large cities and economically strong regions when there are so many weaker communities in need of assistance?
In my view, this is a false dichotomy. Metropolises are not simply large cities. They are powerful economic centres, together with the surrounding areas, linked by a shared labour market, infrastructure, and the daily movement of people. They are natural hubs of economic growth. In modern Ukraine, given the complex demographic situation, and the aftermath of the war, the role of such territories is only growing in importance.
A significant proportion of the country’s population and economic activity is concentrated in large cities and the surrounding communities. If the state creates the conditions for their development, even relatively small investments in shared infrastructure can yield a tangible economic impact. This means new jobs, higher tax revenues, additional investment, and greater opportunities for the reconstruction of other regions.
Therefore, supporting metropolitan areas does not contradict the principle of solidarity between regions. On the contrary, the development of strong economic centres can generate additional resources to support the regions that have suffered most from the war.
There is another important aspect – resilience. Large cities and their agglomerations concentrate a significant proportion of the population, businesses, and critical infrastructure. Therefore, they have specific needs in terms of protection, the redundancy of life-support systems, and ensuring the continuity of services. Cooperation between communities allows for a more effective response to these challenges as well.
Therefore, metropolitan governance should be viewed not only as a tool for local development, but also as one of the elements of post-war recovery and the strengthening of Ukraine’s resilience.
Another important issue that emerged during the Forum was the lack of a common understanding of terminology.
We often use the terms “agglomeration”, “metropolis”, “functional territory”, and “inter-municipal cooperation” interchangeably. Yet they describe different things. In my view, it is worth distinguishing between the geographical and administrative aspects.
Functional territories can form around large cities, in rural, mountainous, or border regions, or around several approximately equal-sized localities.
They can have different structures: monocentric or polycentric.
A metropolis is one type of such territory. It usually refers to a large city with a significant sphere of influence, extending to surrounding communities for tens of kilometres. Classic examples in Ukraine include the Kyiv, Lviv, and other large urban metropolitan territories.
However, the existence of a metropolis as a functional territory does not in any way imply that a formal institution for cooperation is already in place there. A metropolis can exist economically and geographically even without a separate governing body.
In contrast, inter-municipal cooperation is not limited to metropolises. Rural, mountainous, border, and other communities are equally in need of joint decisions. Ukraine therefore needs a policy for the development of different types of functional territories, not just large urban agglomerations.
One of the objectives of the III International Forum of Agglomerations was not merely to discuss specific projects or governance models. We wanted to draw attention to the very topic of horizontal cooperation between communities. After all, despite the successes of decentralisation, Ukraine still lacks a systematic vision of how links between communities should develop and what the state’s role should be in these processes.
Therefore, it was important for us to involve representatives of the central government, Ukrainian communities, international organisations, experts, and European metropolises. We are grateful to our media partners, in particular the Decentralisation portal, for their help in publicising these discussions. Thanks to the live online broadcast, an international audience was also able to join in.
I am convinced that such discussions must continue. We should not seek a single, universal model for the whole of Ukraine. The Lviv metropolis, the border communities of Zakarpattia, and the rural territories of central Ukraine may require different tools for cooperation. But the principle should be the same: communities should be able to join forces where this yields the best results for residents.
The state should not only permit such cooperation, but also provide financial incentives for it.
For me, the main conclusion of the Forum is simple: decentralisation has made Ukrainian communities stronger. Now our task is to make them stronger together.
The next step should not be yet another round of discussions about administrative models, but specific government decisions that will provide communities with the resources for joint projects.
The column reflects the opinion of its author only. The author is responsible for ensuring the accuracy of the information. The views expressed in the column may not coincide with those of the editorial staff of the Decentralisation Portal.
20 November 2026
Безбар'єрність як частина післявоєнної відбудови: досвід відновлення Тростянецької лікарні
Безбар'єрність як частина післявоєнної...
Під час російської окупації в підвалі Тростянецької міської лікарні приймали пологи – там народилося 21...
20 November 2026
Return of abducted Ukrainian children – a...
On 20 November 2026, in Brussels, during the first meeting of the Joint Consultative Committee between the European...
20 November 2026
European standards need resources: What...
Ukrainian communities need not only new operating rules in line with European Union legislation, but also experts,...
20 November 2026
Ukrainian local self-government gained a...
On 20 November 2026, the first meeting of the Joint Consultative Committee between the European Committee of the...